Skip to content

Segregation as Custom – Hedgepeth v. Trenton Board of Education

NJ250 exhibit banner with a background image of an unspecified map and text NJ250 Living Documents, Evolving Rights 1776-2026

How can a school district flagrantly defy the law for decades? 

A New Jersey Reform Era Court Ruling

Change is Slow 

While the 13th Amendment freed all enslaved persons throughout the country in spirit, segregation and discrimination were still present in all aspects of society for decades. While the South was very slow to adopt changes to treat African Americans as equals, many other states took bold actions to enshrine anti-discrimination into laws, particularly education.


Well before the infamous Brown v. Board of Education case, New Jersey was a leader, at the state level, of codifying equality in education. As early as 1881, New Jersey passed a law making it illegal to discriminate against children in public schools based on their color.


Yet, despite the efforts of the NJ Legislature, there was no active enforcement so many school districts in the state still implemented discriminatory policies against African Americans. However, in 1943, an event would occur that would lay the foundation for widespread change and become a pillar for the prosecution in Brown v. Board of Education.


calendar1943

School’s Out For Summer

In June 1943, the students in the School District of Trenton were getting ready for summer vacation and some were excited to move on to different schools next school year. Two African American students, Janet Hedgepath and Leon Williams, were informed that they would be attending New Lincoln School for junior high, two and a half miles away, instead of Junior High School No. 2 which was only a few blocks away.

The New Lincoln School

New Lincoln School was built in 1923 with the expressed purpose of being a school dedicated solely for African American students and it was the policy of the Trenton Board of Education that all African American junior high students would be sent to New Lincoln School. In fact, Mayor Frederick Donnelly used the creation of New Lincoln School as support for his 1924 campaign slogan, “A True Friend of the Colored Race”.

Chart the Case

Click below to view a brief summary of the exhibit in a timeline format.
June 1943

Two black elementary school students, Janet Hedgepath and Leon Williams were informed that they would attend the all black Lincoln School instead of the much closer Junior High School No. 2 next school year.

9/2/1943

After repeated petitions to have their children attend a closer school, the Trenton Board of Education refused to take action on the petitions by Gladys Hedgepath and Berline Williams.

9/16/1943

Gladys Hedgepath files suit with the NJ Supreme Court. The Court demands Trenton Board of Education respond by October 4th.

12/3/1943

After several continuances, the case was finely argued before the NJ Supreme Court with Robert Queen representing Gladys Hedgepath and Henry M. Hartmann representing the Trenton Board of Education.

1/31/1944

The NJ Supreme Court determined that the Trenton Board of Education violated the rights of the children and engaged in discrimination.


Upon hearing of this, the parents of Janet and Leon, Gladys and Berline, petitioned the Superintendent of School, Paul Loser multiple times to allow their children to attend the closer all-white junior high school. In response, Mr. Loser responded:

“Pending final decision by the Board of Education your daughter, Jane is assigned to the New Lincoln School.”


—Paul Loser, Superintendent of School

The Trenton Board of Education failed to take Gladys’ petition up at their September 2nd meeting so both Janet and Leon were forced to attend the all African American New Lincoln School.

calendar1943

The Fight Intensifies

The school year started on September 13th and three days later, Gladys Hedgepeth filed suit with the NJ Supreme Court, alleging that the Trenton Board of Education was discriminating against African American students by forcing them into a substandard and segregated school. African American attorney and local NAACP activist Robert Queen represented Galdys and would have some tense exchanges with Superintendent of Schools Paul Loser.

calendar1943

A Violation of Rights

In her suit, Gladys alleges that her daughter Janet was discriminated against because of her race, which violates Section 18:14-2 of the Revised Statues of New Jersey 1937. That status specifically states:


In addition to alleging discrimination based on “color”, Gladys also alleged that accommodations of Junior High School No. 2 and the New Lincoln School were not equal, resulting in a “substandard and foreshortened school”. In fact, the principal of New Lincoln School was responsible for overseeing over 2,500 students with support staff while the principal at Junior High School No. 2 was only responsible for 691 with a vice-principal and an assistant principal. Additionally, there were more courses offered to students at Junior High School No. 2 compared with New Lincoln School, some of which Janet was more interested int taking. As a result, Gladys also charged that the Trenton Board of Education violated Section 10:1-2 of the Revised Statues of New Jersey 1937:

calendar1943 – 1944

A Snails Pace

Originally, the NJ Supreme Court requested a response from the Trenton Board of Education by October 4th, but after 2 continuances, the case would finally be heard on December 3rd.

During arguments, there was a tense exchange between Robert Queen, Henry Hartmann and Justice Porter that brought the racial disparities to bare. It would take less than 2 months for the NJ Supreme Court to render its verdict that the Trenton School District’s districting policy based on race was wholly and undoubtedly unconstitutional.

calendar1944 – 1945

An Aftermath of Letters

In the aftermath of the Hedgepeth decision, the Trenton Board of Education determined that the best way to comply with the NJ Supreme Court’s ruling was to only move students out of the New Lincoln School upon written request of the parent. This created a firestorm in the community with many parents writing letters to transfer their students from the school as well as letters from residents condemning the policy. Some civic organizations even got involved condemning this policy, including veiled threats of further legal action.

True desegregation would still take years to achieve. In 1947, a new State Constitution was passed, expressly prohibiting segregation in public schools. In 1954, segregation of any form in schools is outlawed at the federal level as a result of the seminal United States Supreme Court decision Brown v. Board of Education. In 1965, the N.J. Supreme Court case, Booker v. Plainfield Board of Education, helped further outlaw segregation at the state level while requiring school boards to take all necessary steps to eliminate segregation in any form from their district.

feather quill penQuestions for Discussion:

  • Does it surprise you to learn that New Jersey codified anti-discrimination in public schools long before Brown v. Board of Education?
  • Why do you think the Trenton Board of Education was so resistive to change and compliance?
  • If you lived in Trenton in 1945, would you have wrote a letter and if so, what would it say?

Share your thoughts with us on New Jersey history.

NJ250 Exhibition from the NJ State Library, in partnership with New Jersey State Archives.

NJ State Library Exhibitions